Battle Forge

Silvanoshi EA Staff 3,955 Berlin · #1 19.11.2009, 15:00

This is the official discussion thread for the Stormsinger card. Only post your feedback on this specific card in this thread, please DO NOT post anything about other cards here. All posts post must be related to the Stormsinger card. Off topic posts will be deleted.

You may make use of the poll, however, we prefer statements in the thread that further explain your thinking. While backing up your points with examples is encouraged, try not to get carried away, and start arguing for the sake of arguing.

Silvanoshi

Rancord 1,996 Ruschlikon · #2 19.11.2009, 15:05

maybee make tha abillity much cheaper, so it is an option over surge

Draconnor 1,379 Płock · #3 19.11.2009, 15:07

This one have simply to weak stats ...

It can be buffed in Lightsblade Way - to make it good in pvp only
or it can have buffed dmg for pvp and pve.

In theory i could ask about different skill but like for Amazon - stats is propably all that she can get ;) but this time stats would quite enough imo. Becouse actualy she is strong T1 not T2 ;) (and must stay T2 due to swift)

Savis 277 · #4 19.11.2009, 15:09

As I said many times, it finds no place in the deck because:
- GS is not pure and is better
- good vs EP only

BigOmar 63 · #5 19.11.2009, 15:09

buff the attack

Aliyon 5,421 Just a guy in the USA · #6 19.11.2009, 15:09

The biggest changes needed are a faster speed on the ability projectile and a larger range for the ability.

A damage buff might be nice too.

ninjaflute 1,973 UK · #7 19.11.2009, 15:11

would be nice to tweak her ability or increase her damage (neither will do, don't need both)

1. reduce the ability power cost to 40.
2. increae her damage to 75 per shot.

Harlequin 5,797 Waiting for Grim Dawn · #8 19.11.2009, 15:12

I think she needs two things

1. A rangebuff for her ability
2. A speedbuff for the spear. It flies way too slow.

possible:

decrease costs for her or her ability.
increase damage.

Praseee 1,519 · #9 19.11.2009, 15:27

this unit is useless because:
1. Her stats sucks
2. She cant hit ANY moving target, so the fact she is ranged is really worthless

= She is totaly useless in fight

3. Her ability casts too long
4. Its better to use Gravity Surge in every way

= she is useless in general.

So, if you want to make this unit worth playing, make her worth using, there is no need of lowering ability cost, it would be fine, if she was able to fight a little bit.

You have to look at it like this - She is unit with Gravity Surge as ability, so if you take her into deck, you could possibly spare 1 deck slot, but like it is right now, its 100% better to make 1 Lyrish Knight and use Gravity Surge instead her.

hounou 112 Helsinki Finland · #10 19.11.2009, 15:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aliyon

The biggest changes needed are a faster speed on the ability projectile and a larger range for the ability.

A damage buff might be nice too.

agree

View Poll Results: Does Stormsinger need an adjustment?
Yes, definitely! The card is way too strong, please nerf it!	27	7.30%
Nope, I think the card works fine the way it is. No changes needed.	56	15.14%
Yes, the card is way too weak. Please make it stronger.	287	77.57%
Voters: 370. You may not vote on this poll

#1 19.11.2009, 15:00
Silvanoshi EA Staff 3,955 Berlin	Watch List - Stormsinger This is the official discussion thread for the Stormsinger card. Only post your feedback on this specific card in this thread, please DO NOT post anything about other cards here. All posts post must be related to the Stormsinger card. Off topic posts will be deleted. You may make use of the poll, however, we prefer statements in the thread that further explain your thinking. While backing up your points with examples is encouraged, try not to get carried away, and start arguing for the sake of arguing. Silvanoshi __________________ Chris "Silvanoshi" Murphy, Community Representative, EA CommunityTeam (Forum Rules) Follow me on my personal Twitter account : Silvanoshi_EA. Follow BattleForge on Facebook & Twitter.
	Join Date: 06.07.2009

#2 19.11.2009, 15:05
Rancord 1,996 Ruschlikon	maybee make tha abillity much cheaper, so it is an option over surge
	Join Date: 11.05.2008

#3 19.11.2009, 15:07
Draconnor 1,379 Płock	This one have simply to weak stats ... It can be buffed in Lightsblade Way - to make it good in pvp only or it can have buffed dmg for pvp and pve. In theory i could ask about different skill but like for Amazon - stats is propably all that she can get ;) but this time stats would quite enough imo. Becouse actualy she is strong T1 not T2 ;) (and must stay T2 due to swift) __________________ about 20 +/-1 rank in pvp - best position in rank 92 // 25 years living and 18 years playing ___ Primeval Wather on Watch List please ... and something Anti Air for nature would be nice ... ___ Tested Starcraft 2 and happily back to Battleforge... 12 units per side, boring gathering of resources and no auto-grouping of units .... its realy not for me anymore ...
	Join Date: 06.08.2009

#4 19.11.2009, 15:09
Savis 277	As I said many times, it finds no place in the deck because: - GS is not pure and is better - good vs EP only
	Join Date: 12.06.2009

#5 19.11.2009, 15:09
BigOmar 63	buff the attack
	Join Date: 02.08.2009

#6 19.11.2009, 15:09
Aliyon 5,421 Just a guy in the USA	The biggest changes needed are a faster speed on the ability projectile and a larger range for the ability. A damage buff might be nice too. __________________ Decks: Soulfrost: (PPBB), Ghostchill: (PBPB) BattleForge Wiki : Everything you ever wanted to know about BattleForge! Find me at: BattleForge IRC, My Wiki Page, My BFCards Profile My Brutes: Aliyon, Kaida
	Join Date: 29.11.2008

#7 19.11.2009, 15:11
ninjaflute 1,973 UK	would be nice to tweak her ability or increase her damage (neither will do, don't need both) 1. reduce the ability power cost to 40. 2. increae her damage to 75 per shot. __________________ 西风吹吹，落地生根，东风吹吹，落叶归根. watch Legends fail: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erB71amnozo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wygurGBiVv4
	Join Date: 09.03.2009

#8 19.11.2009, 15:12
Harlequin 5,797 Waiting for Grim Dawn	I think she needs two things 1. A rangebuff for her ability 2. A speedbuff for the spear. It flies way too slow. possible: decrease costs for her or her ability. increase damage. __________________ http://www.grimdawn.com/index.php The spiritual successor of Titan Quest. If you loved Titan Quest you have to check this out! This will be the best ARPG of the next year. Screw Diablo 3. Geistiger Nachfolger von Titan Quest. Wenn ihr Titan Quest mochtet solltet ihr euch das unbedingt ansehen!
	Join Date: 09.08.2008

#9 19.11.2009, 15:27
Praseee 1,519	this unit is useless because: 1. Her stats sucks 2. She cant hit ANY moving target, so the fact she is ranged is really worthless = She is totaly useless in fight 3. Her ability casts too long 4. Its better to use Gravity Surge in every way = she is useless in general. So, if you want to make this unit worth playing, make her worth using, there is no need of lowering ability cost, it would be fine, if she was able to fight a little bit. You have to look at it like this - She is unit with Gravity Surge as ability, so if you take her into deck, you could possibly spare 1 deck slot, but like it is right now, its 100% better to make 1 Lyrish Knight and use Gravity Surge instead her. __________________ http://dskfmn-wi.mybrute.com
	Join Date: 10.04.2009